Before choosing where to spend their money, customers read the reviews, and they read how the owner replied. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey of United States (US) consumers, 89% expect owners to respond to reviews 1. Some 42% say they are unlikely to use a business that never replies 1.
Keeping up is the hard part. After a full working day, few owners have the energy to write a considered reply to every review. Threads go unanswered, and complaints sit in public view.
Google has noticed the backlog. In March 2026, Search Engine Land reported a Google Business Profile test that suggests Artificial Intelligence (AI) replies for owners to edit and submit 2. In June 2026, Google followed with an announcement that owners can connect their profile to Gemini, which drafts review replies in the brand's own voice 3.
Notice the verb in both announcements: draft. Gemini writes the reply, but neither announcement says it publishes anything. Someone still has to open the profile, check each draft and post it, one review at a time.
Drafting is only half the job. The other half, logging in, checking and posting, still lands on the owner's desk. And once every competitor can produce a draft in seconds, a fast draft stops being an advantage.
BrightLocal found that 80% of US consumers are likely to use a business that responds to all reviews 1. Yet 50% are put off by replies that read as generic or templated 1. That is a larger group than the 42% put off by no reply at all.
Google is careful about what replies do for you. Its local ranking guidance says replying shows customers you value their feedback, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help your ranking 4. It makes no such promise for the replies themselves.
Different reviews also need different handling. A five-star review earns a prompt, specific thank-you, while a one-star review needs empathy, the facts and an offer to settle it offline. A generic draft knows none of those facts.
So should AI handle your reviews? Yes, provided it knows how your business deals with each kind of review, and you decide how much a person checks before anything goes live.
Unsure where to draw the line? Let routine positive replies publish themselves, and have a person approve anything under four stars or anything that names a complaint.
Italian DesAIgns' fully customized Review Responder goes further: it writes the reply and posts it too. For each client, we connect Gemini to a knowledge base of the business's own cases, which it consults before every reply (retrieval-augmented generation, RAG). Because that knowledge base covers every rating from one to five stars, each reply reflects how the business really handles that situation.
Run fully automated, it answers every review with no one at the keyboard. Prefer to stay in control? The same system holds each reply for one-click approval, and you can see its work on our own Google Business Profile.
The Review Responder is one of our AI automation services. See how we set it up, and which other everyday tasks we automate for clients, on that page.
- Italian DesAIgns
References & Citations
- [1]BrightLocal: Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (2026).
- [2]Search Engine Land: Google Business Profile Tests AI-Generated Replies to Reviews (2026).
- [3]Google: Save Time and Grow Your Business With New Gemini Tools (2026).
- [4]Google Business Profile Help: Tips to Improve Your Local Ranking on Google (2026).